[Muslim].
Commentary:
1. Some people try to deduce a proof for good innovations from the words: "Mun sana' fi Al- islam sunah hasanah". Whosoever introduces a good practice in Islam.
Thus they classify innovations Bid`ah into two categories, namely good innovations and bad innovations. But this is wrong. No innovation can be good. It is always bad because it amounts to inventing Shar`iah which no one has the right to do. Constitution of Shar`iah is the exclusive Right of Allah Alone. It is He who constitutes the Shar`iah and it is on His behest that His Prophets convey it to the people. Not to speak of scholars and others.
2. What this Hadith makes abundantly clear is that anyone who tries to find new ways and means to preach and practice Islamic Shar`iah, which are later on adopted by other people also, would not only get the reward of doing so but he will also be rewarded for the endeavours of those who will after him continue them and perform good deeds. But anything of which we do not find any trace in Shar`iah is bad. It cannot be good in any case, no matter what means are adopted for this purpose.
3. Other benefits of this Hadith are self-evident and do not need further elaboration.
[ النمار ] جمع نمرة وهي كساء من صوف مخطط
ومعنى [ مجتابيها ] : لابسيها قد خرقوها في رؤوسهم . والجوب : القطع ومنه قول الله تعالى ( الفجر 9 ) : { وثمود الذين جابوا الصخر بالواد } : أي نحتوه وقطعوه
وقوله [ تمعر ] هو بالعين المهملة : أي تغير
وقوله [ رأيت كومين ] بفتح الكاف وضمها أي : صبرتين
وقوله [ كأنه مذهبة ] هو بالذال المعجمة وفتح الهاء والباء الموحدة . قاله القاضي عياض وغيره . وصحفه بعضهم فقال : [ مدهنة ] بدال مهملة وضم الهاء وبالنون وكذا ضبطه الحميدي والصحيح المشهور هو الأول . والمراد به على الوجهين : الصفاء والاستنارة PageV01P211