in a fut≠wwa, anyone who, he felt, was gradually deviating from the source for all ontological meaning, i.e. God and the sunnå of the Prophet. In terms of attributing the customs of an organization as a sunnå, he stated, “It is imperative to differentiate between following the Prophet and making a sunnå of his practice, and a practice which though it was connected with the Prophet was not intended as a sunnå and is therefore a piece of innovation (bida).”43 Ibn-Taym⁄ya did not agree with many areas of the specific rites of the fityån, especially when its proponents defended their ideas with the Qurån and shar⁄å. But in all of his criticisms it is important to recognize that he did not condemn the institution as a whole and advocate the dissolving of the fut≠wwa institution. Another contemporary Hanbal⁄ thinker and student of Ibn- Taym⁄ya, Såfi al-D⁄n Idr⁄s ibn Bidq⁄n, was much more uncom- promising against the fut≠wwa groups.44 Ibn-Bidq⁄n went further than Ibn-Taym⁄ya by stating that what he witnessed in the fut≠wwa groups was the worst form of bida. According to him, anyone asso- ciated with the fityåns had totally diverged from the principles of the shar⁄å and sunnå. While Ibn-Taym⁄ya mainly argued against their text sources for defending fut≠wwa rituals, Ibn-Bidq⁄n attacked the popular practices themselves as bida. He accused elder fityån members of practicing sodomy with younger initiate fata members during the ritual of libås al-fut≠wwa. For Ibn-Bidq⁄n, the tying of one or more knots in the ends of fata’s girdle, belt or shawl and being in the presence of the “beardless youths” was absolutely forbidden by the Prophet.45 In the sources that are available not all of the initiation rites are written in such detail to support Ibn- Bidq⁄n’s allegations, which is a major a problem in fully analyzing what Ibn-Bidq⁄n observed and the fut≠wwa texts that are extant. What is distinct is the difference in Ibn-Taym⁄ya’s arguments against fityån claims of having pietistic roots in the shar⁄å, whereas Ibn-Bidq⁄n finds the popular practices within the fut≠wwa institu- tion problematic as a whole and against all Islamic principles. Even with scholarly criticism by Ibn-Taym⁄ya and condemna- tion by Ibn-Bidq⁄n, both of the works by Ibn al-Mimar and al- Khartabirti are interested in not only preserving the history and philosophy of fityån, but more importantly, their writings promote a particular interpretation of Islamic worship. Both works, Kitåb al-fut≠wwa and Tuhfåt ål-Wasaya, stress the Qurånic significance in being members of fut≠wwa groups and how as members they are carrying forward, through rituals and beliefs, the message of the Prophet. Supporters like Ibn al-Mimar and al-Khartabirti
THE LIFE OF SHAIKH ‘ABÁ HAFS UMAR AL-SUHRAWARDÛ