single action is directly supported by the orders of God. He argues that any fut≠wwa organization that is not grounded in the prin- ciples of shar⁄a is not a true fut≠wwa because fityån groups initiate members with only the highest moral qualities. And since the fityån groups that he is familiar with require the individual fata members first to prove their ability to reason (aql) and demonstrate their knowledge (ilm) of shar⁄å, this combination of the two main- tains a strong level of sound minded members who can distinguish right and from wrong.34 He even criticizes the factionalism among fityån groups such as the “Bayt al-Maulidiya” or the “Bayt ash-Shuhayniya,” and it is interesting to point out that he credits caliph al-Nåsir with putting an end to these divisions with his fut≠wwa reforms. Ibn al-Mimar explains that caliph al-Nåsir’s guidance under Shaikh Abd al-Jabbår, who initiated him into the “Bayt ar-Rahhåsiya” fut≠wwa, understood the importance of uniting the fityån groups because they were moving further away from the ideals of the fut≠wwa.35 It is likely that Ibn al-Mimar’s and al-Khartabirti’s extensive work was to prove that fityån groups were completely in harmony with the Islamic shar⁄å in order to defend the institution from crit- icism. This validity of fityån groups and the issue of whether their practices and beliefs were in compliance with Islamic principles was still an important controversy for the ulamå in the late thirteenth century. For example, one important Hanbal⁄ jurist scholar (faqih) who spoke out against fityån groups and all of the rituals that were created within the fityån was Shaikh Ibn-Taym⁄ya (1263–1328). While there is a considerable amount of scholarship on Ibn- Taym⁄ya, it is clear that recent studies show the complexity of his thought as well as the difficulty in labeling him either a reformer or a proponent of a sunn⁄ orthodoxy.36 In Muhammad Umar Memon’s work on Ibn-Taym⁄ya, he clearly illustrates how certain scholars only focus on the later years of Ibn-Taym⁄ya’s polemical works. During the later years of 1321–1326, Ibn-Taym⁄ya wit- nessed a breakdown in Muslim–Christian relations where wide- spread riots fueled popular resentment. Also during this time, Ibn- Taym⁄ya was imprisoned for his contentious polemical writings, such as, “The Necessity of the Straight Path against the People of Hell” (Kitåb iqtidå as-siråt al-mustaq⁄m mukhålafat ashåb al- jah⁄m). In Kitåb iqtidå as-siråtal-mustaq⁄m, Ibn-Taym⁄ya expands upon a theory on the subject of innovative additions (bida) to the Islamic religion which he believes stems from non-Islamic practices and customs.37 His view of history relies heavily on degrees of
THE LIFE OF SHAIKH ‘ABÁ HAFS UMAR AL-SUHRAWARDÛ