questions as to why the fut≠wwa organizations became an essen- tial policy issue for caliph al-Nåsir. What did caliph al-Nåsir benefit from fut≠wwa groups in social, political and religious terms? How could centralizing fut≠wwa organizations with the caliph at the center of all authority change the function of fityån? And was it possible for caliph al-Nåsir to consolidate fut≠wwa organizations without the assistance of Shaikh al-Suhraward⁄? These issues are very controversial for scholars like Claude Cahen who believed that al-Nåsir recognized the fut≠wwa order in part to spread the ideas of al-Suhraward⁄, the principal propagan- dist of fut≠wwa reforms and one of the most revered men of his day.21 Cahen believed that early ideas in reforming fut≠wwa organizations were probably not from the caliph himself, but from shaikh al-Suhraward⁄. To him Shaikh al-Suhraward⁄ was the mastermind in designing the religious, political, and social reforms of fut≠wwa organizations, because they increased the shaikh’s opportunity to advance his particular form of s≠f⁄ islam to fut≠wwa members who were already sympathetic to s≠f⁄ ideals. It also allowed al-Suhraward⁄ to recruit members to his tar⁄qa and expand Suhraward⁄ khånaqåhs in the western regions. Cahen does not diminish the importance of caliph al-Nåsir’s expansionary policies, but in regard to altering the religio-political philosophy of fityån, Shaikh al-Suhraward⁄ should be given primary credit. One of the ways in which Cahen proved that al-Suhraward⁄’s efforts were essential to reconstructing fut≠wwa organizations was by using al-Suhraward⁄’s innovative political and religious beliefs in ta‚awwuf. To Cahen, Shaikh al-Suhraward⁄ developed a theory for unifying the caliphate in a way that fityån and ta‚awwuf islam were essentially one single entity. And both of these entities belonged under the supervision of the caliph, where the descending order after the caliph was s≠f⁄ †ar⁄qåts, then the fityån which were really a subordinate part of the s≠f⁄ †ar⁄qåts. According to Cahen, this theory certainly did not conflict with al-Nåsir’s political ambi- tions and his conception of himself as the primary leader of fut≠wwa organizations. Cahen believed it was through the signifi- cant collaborative and intellectual efforts of al-Suhraward⁄ that caliph al-Nåsir was successful in making himself the final authority in fut≠wwa organizations, as well as expanding his power as the caliph. Two authors of this period who studied fut≠wwa structure, ideas, beliefs and rituals were Ibn al-Mimar al-Baghdåd⁄ and al-Khartabirti. In Ibn al-Mimar’s Kitåb al-fut≠wwa there are
THE LIFE OF SHAIKH ‘ABÁ HAFS UMAR AL-SUHRAWARDÛ