worship” of s≠f⁄ shaikhs, and the convergence of philosophy with mystical theology. Essentially, modern Muslim reformers call for a process of internal purification of Islamic thought, practice, and education in order to return to the glory days of high Islamdom culture.3 One of the main historical problems that still exist in studying the s≠f⁄ tradition is the acceptance of the ulamå versus s≠f⁄ para- digm. Scholars like Ira Lapidus, Marshall Hodgson and Fazlur Rahman used this two-tiered model where there is a normative official religion organized under the authority of the clerics and designed for the cultural elite.4 Any deviation from the “main- stream official religion” is an aberration from the original doctrines of Islam and such practices are followed by the masses or commonly referred to as “popular religion.” Until recently, s≠f⁄s were categorized under the title of popular religion which was based on fixed, superstitious, misguided beliefs and practices in- fluenced by other religious traditions. It was suggested that the people who practiced these s≠f⁄ beliefs were illiterate, anarchistic, and opponents to the religion of the literate clerics. Also, the masses who took part in “popular religion” were not susceptible to histori- cal changes or capable of contributing intellectually to the tradi- tion.5 Fazlur Rahman argued that the appeal of the s≠f⁄ tradition was due to the deceptive and spiritual demagogy of s≠f⁄ shaikhs supports this line of thinking. He stated the following:
Instead of being a method of moral self-discipline and elevation and genuine spiritual enlightenment, S≠fism was now transformed into veritable spiritual jugglery through auto-hypnotic transports and visions just as at the level of doctrine it was being transmuted into a half-delirious theosophy.6
Fortunately, S≠f⁄ studies have progressed since Rahman with works specializing in s≠f⁄ thought, mystical theology, s≠f⁄ author- ity, the ta‚awwuf path, ethics, epistemology, and analysis of models of the s≠f⁄ journey. Some recent works by Th. Emil Homerin, Valeri Hoffman, Vincent Cornell, and Stephen Hirtenstein have given the field of S≠f⁄ studies a new way of thinking about s≠f⁄s and their religious practices.7 These works are important in many respects because these authors, and others, have analyzed s≠f⁄ authority, the mystical teachings of s≠f⁄ shaikhs, the conduct of s≠f⁄ disciples with mediating s≠f⁄ shaikhs, critical theories of s≠f⁄ theology, and s≠f⁄
INTRODUCTION