in the heart of Delhi, which perhaps contributed to his dislike for s≠f⁄s involved in government service, or s≠f⁄ acceptance of state endowments. These biases against Shaikh Baha al-d⁄n Zakariyyå and the Suhraward⁄ silsilå were in the forefront of debate about accumulating wealth. For the shaikh, wealth and devotion to ta‚awwuf were not incompatible. Shaikh Zakariyyå defended his position against critics by explaining that it was not so much the wealth, but its improper use that was detrimental to spiritual progress. Opponents of Shaikh Zakariyyå’s ideas would often state that, “Two opposites cannot meet at one single place.”27 In one situation, Shaikh Zakariyyå attended a court proceeding convened by Sultån Iltutmish and was questioned by a well-known opponent, Shaikh Óam⁄d al-d⁄n Sawal⁄, about the sources from which he acquired his wealth. The shaikh’s response was: “Wealth is clearly a venomous serpent. But poison does not harm one who knows the antidote.” Again the critic attacked Shaikh Zakariyyå in front of the sultån by asking, “Where is the necessity of keeping a dirty venomous creature and then depending on an antidote for safety.” Shaikh Zakariyyå immediately replied by stating: “Your s≠f⁄ has no beauty or attraction. Our s≠f⁄ has immense beauty, and wealth is like a black dot averting the evil effect of jealous glances.”28 Shaikh Zakariyyå’s response to Shaikh Sawal⁄’s line of questioning reflects Zakariyyå’s consistent need to defend him- self on the subject of accepting financial or land endowments. On the subject of Shaikh Zakariyyå’s views on wealth, there is an interesting historiographical dichotomy in the writings of various s≠f⁄ hagiographers. For instance, among the well-known Chisht⁄ hagiographers like Am⁄r Sijz⁄ and M⁄r Kh≠rd, they consistently recollected the “negative qualities or controversial issues” of Shaikh Zakariyyå. Their accounts rarely discuss his personal piety, devotion to ta‚awwuf, s≠f⁄ teachings and interpretations, and his generous donations to the community. But Jamal⁄, a devout Suhra- ward⁄ member and one of the first Suhraward⁄ hagiographers, recorded these “positive qualities” in response to Am⁄r Sijz⁄ and M⁄r Kh≠rd to refute what was recorded in Chisht⁄ sources. Even when Jamal⁄ concentrates on Zakariyyå’s personal piety and ta‚awwuf teachings, he does not dismiss or reduce the importance of Am⁄r Sijz⁄ and M⁄r Kh≠rd’s works as historically inaccurate. It is important to remember that Jamal⁄ does not include his personal opinions on the Chisht⁄ order or attempt to slander them by suggesting that their records are politically motivated to degrade the reputation of Shaikh Zakariyyå. But instead, Jamal⁄ is
MULTANÛ SUHRAWARDÛ TAÍAWWUF SPIRITUAL EXERCISES