Unlike Turner and Singer, Tambiah focuses on the opposing forces that are in rituals such as the cultural versus the universal, and form versus content. The diversity of opinions within the per- forming theorists’ school of thought have contributed to ritual studies, particularly on metaphors of the acts of drama. But still there remain methodological problems that have not been resolved. For instance, every ritual is understood as a social drama and is viewed as a performance that contains symbolic acts meant for the audience and is open to any interpretation. The only criterion for rituals is described in terms of performances; essentially, the model of ritual activity classifies the criterion for what is or is not ritual. Another deficiency for the performing theorists is that since every ritual activity is a performance, it is difficult to distinguish cultural rituals from dramatic theater or an entertaining sports event. One of the main criticisms of performing theorists is that they do not recognize that cultural and religious rituals have the potential to connect to another spiritual world. They refuse to accept that these rituals are channels to access a separate dimension, such as a request for intercession. For performing theorists, anything beyond the obvious characteristics of the actors and audience is open to speculation, even if the discussion comes from the actors them- selves. On one level they are prepared to explain the symbolic meanings of ritual activities, but they do not progress to the next reasonable level of what the symbols mean to those who perform them. The different studies on ritual activities by the functionalists, structuralists, and performing theorists have offered certain theo- retical models, all of which center around the problems of the relationship between thought and action. This basic dichotomy in the field is pertinent as it affects the relationships of the observer- theorist and the actors. This fundamental division between thought and action differentiates a thinking subject from an acting object, or as some have concluded a thinking subject from a non-thinking object. In the same ritual discourse, rituals are an object to better understand the culture because they integrate the subject’s thought and the object’s activities. The issue of whether rituals are a part of conceptual classification or are the source for cultural expres- sions to be integrated through both thought and action is an important aspect on how theorists construct or deconstruct mean- ings from rituals. The work of Marcel Mauss brings a refreshing balance to the field of ritual studies by explaining that “social systems are wholes,
SACRED IDENTITIES IN THE SUHRAWARDÛYYA ORDER