The English Translations & the Commentaries of the Holy Qur'aan — Qur'aan Made Easy
/ ১২৫৩
📝 লেখা 📖 পিডিএফ

Self Opinionated Tafseer is Haraam and Forbidden in the Shariah Rasulullaah (SallAllaahu Alayhi Wasallam) said: “Whosoever says anything from his own opinion in matters of The Quraan should prepare his abode in the Fire.” In another tradition it is mentioned: “Whosoever says anything in matters of The Quraan without knowledge should prepare his abode in Jahannam.” (SunanAtTirmidhi). One Injeel further states: “Whosoever speaks in matter of The Quraan with mere self opinion and utters that which is correct, then he too has erred.” In short, he who deviates in his explanation from the views of the Sahaabah (RA) and the Taabi'een is wrong; nay, he is a mistaken innovator, even though he is a Mujtahid (trying honestly to reach the truth) and will hopefully be forgiven by Allaah. We have discussed various methods of knowledge and ways of knowing the truth. We know that the Sahaabah (RA), the Taabi'een and their followers studied The Quraan very carefully, and that they knew the meaning and the interpretation of its verses better than anyone else, just as they knew best the truth which Allaah revealed to Rasulullaah (SallAllaahu Alayhi Wasallam). Hence, those who deviate from their views, and explain The Quraan on different lines are wrong both in the ideas they expound and the arguments to offer. Their ideas have no value. Commentary by Self-Opinion Imaam Suyooti (RA) writes in his famous book Al itqaan on the authority of Ibn Naqeeb (RA) that there are five ways of providing commentary by self¬ opinion. 1. To comment without acquiring the relevant sciences of Deen. 2. A person begins to comment on the Mutashaabihaat (the ambiguous verses of The Quraan) the meaning and object of which are known to Allaah alone. 3. To comment in such a manner to prove correct a deviated school of thought. 4. To assert absolutely about a certain verse without proof that Allaah Ta'aala definitely meant a certain thing. 5. To comment merely according to one's desire and fancy. (Al Itqaan Li Uloomil Quraan v. 2p. 183). The Israelite Traditions Israelite Ahaadeeth are not to be believed; they can only be used as supporting evidence. There are three kinds of Israelite Ahaadeeth. • One that we can regard as true: if they are supported by our Ahaadeeth. • The second category is regarded as false if they are contradicted by our Ahaadeeth. • The third, which fall neither in this category nor in that, because our sources are silent about them. We shall neither believe them nor disbelieve them. They may be quoted as the Hadeeth permits: but let us note that most of them have no value so far as religious matters are concerned.

— পৃষ্ঠা ৩৭ — লেখাটি পিডিএফ থেকে স্বয়ংক্রিয়ভাবে নেওয়া, তাই ভুল থাকতে পারে। সন্দেহ হলে আসল পৃষ্ঠা দেখুন।