General Editor’s Intruduction and Foreword (4) There are no philosophical discussions based on the laws of logic, on syllogisms, induction, deduction, and dialectic; equally there are no didactic and rhetorical questions and answers sessions of the kind even Tabari uses. (5) There are no discussions of symbolism in the Qur’an of the kind described above: neither microcosmic, nor anagogical nor even allegorical or moral. In fact, the very issue of symbolism is not even broached, despite the hadith and the Qur’anic verses mentioned earlier. (6) There are no semantic investigations of Arabic words, and no citations of Jahiliyya poetry as semantic references and guarantees of the connotations, implications and nuances of the words in the Quran. (7) There is no etymological study of the roots of Arabic words and letters and their basic meanings: every Arabic word can be traced to a tri-letteral or quadri-letteral root, and these roots have a basic meaning which is usually connected to some natural (and hence desert) phenomenon; from these ‘root words’ dozens of forms and hundreds of derivatives are produced, such that once the root word is known, the form and the meaning of any derivative word can be deduced. Thus etymology in Arabic, more than in modern languages, is extremely useful in understanding the exact meaning and behaviour of any indigenous word. The Tafsir al-Jalālayn, however, does not delve into this. (8) Anterior to even the meaning of root words in Arabic is the archetypal meaning of the 28 Arabic letters themselves which make up every word in the Arabic language (and ultimately their root meanings), and each one of which has a form, a sound, a behaviour, and even a corresponding number that exactly reflects its archetypal meaning. These archetypal meanings in turn translate into universal principles and thus into lunar house (there are 28 or 29 traditional lunar houses), so that all existent things can ultimately be associated with one of them. This idea — the idea that there is a perfect symbol- ism and exact meaning to every aspect of the Arabic letters — is evidently a difficult and esoteric idea, but it is precisely the foundation of a number of arcane but sacred sciences in Islam. Moreover, more importantly for Tafsir, 29 of the Qur’an’s 114 Sūras or Chapters start with Arabic letters enunciated on their own without forming words (e.g. Alif, Lam, Mim, Nūn; Oāf; Sad, and so on). The Tafsir al-Jalālayn, however, completely ignores this issue, and when it comes to these letters at the beginning of sūras merely remarks: “God knows better what is meant by this”. (9) The Tafsir al-Jalālayn does not explore the traditional Gharā'ib al-Ourān (‘the wondrous- Strange features of the Quran’), and does not address or explain the more complex linguistic tropes to be found in it: it does not explain possible meanings clothed by rhetoric, hyperbole and tautology; it does not delve into puzzling juxtapositions and zeugmas; and does not resolve apparent antinomies and dialectics. It passes over these mines of secret wisdom with very little gloss. (10) More unusually for a tafsīr bil-ma’thir, the Tafsir al-Jalālayn gives no isnāds (chains of transmission) for any of the hadiths it quotes, and mentions earlier Tafsirs to which it is heavily indebted (primarily Tabari) only rarely. This is evidently, as mentioned earlier, in order to keep the Tafsir as simple as possible, since in Suyūtīs al-Durr al-Manthūr, all isnāds are given. (11) With the occasional exception (e.g. the last verses of Sūrat al-Isra’ and Sarat al-Sajda) the Tafsir al-Jalālayn — and this too is unusual for a tafsīr bil-ma’thir — does not relate the Fada il al- Quran: in many of the traditional collections of hadith there are specific sections devoted to what the Prophet (p.b.u.h.) related about the merits of certain verses of the Quran and about effects of reciting them at certain times. These are known as ‘Fada il al-Ourān — literally, ‘the bounties or excellences of the Qur'an’ — and constitute the basis of Islamic supererogatory prayer litanies. They are thus extremely important to practising Muslims, and thus constitute perhaps the strangest omission in the Tafsir al- Jalālayn, since they are relatively brief and few, and would have been easy to relate. (12) There is, in the Tafsir al-Jalālayn, no calling attention to the ‘inner architecture of the Qur'an, showing exactly why certain words and near-synonyms are used in given contexts and not oth- ers, in the fashion made so famous by the late popular Azhari Sheikh and Commentator Muhammad xvii
— পৃষ্ঠা ১৭ —
লেখাটি পিডিএফ থেকে স্বয়ংক্রিয়ভাবে নেওয়া, তাই ভুল থাকতে পারে। সন্দেহ হলে আসল পৃষ্ঠা দেখুন।